Returns Management, Reshaping Retail Profitability

In the fast-paced world of retail, sales numbers and customer acquisition often steal the spotlight. Lurking quietly behind the scenes is a growing challenge that many enterprise retailers are struggling to master: returns management. Once seen as a necessary evil, the handling of product returns has become one of the most complex and costly aspects of modern retail operations.

With the explosive growth of eCommerce, online and in-store return rates have skyrocketed. On average, 16.9% of annual retail sales¹will be returned and in categories such as apparel and electronics this number can be almost twice as much. This creates a logistical and financial burden that few retailers are fully prepared to handle. The ripple effects go far beyond just processing items coming back through the door. Poor return policies frustrate customers, and according to ReturnPro’s 2025 The State of Consumer Returns Survey Report, 82% of shoppers saying that a negative returns experience would impact their decision to shop with a retailer¹. Manual workflows drain labor resources, and the inefficient flow of returned goods through the reverse supply chain causes warehouses to swell with unsellable inventory.

More critically, enterprise retailers face mounting pressures on two fronts:

Profitability: Returns have traditionally been viewed as a cost center, a drain on margins and resources that often go unmanaged or overlooked. With volumes growing and fraud on the rise, returns can quickly erode hard-won revenue. In 2024, 15.14% of all retail returns were fraudulent, costing retailers over $100 billion annually². Fraudulent tactics include wardrobing (buying, using, and returning items),returning stolen goods, and refund abuse³.
Sustainability: In today’s environmentally conscious market, discarded returns contribute to landfill waste, carbon emissions, and reputational risk. Retailers are under intense scrutiny to reduce their environmental impact while maintaining customer satisfaction. In 2025, landfill diversion rates have become a key metric, with reports that indicate millions of tons of returned inventory contribute to landfill waste annually.Retailers and waste management companies are increasingly focusing on landfill diversion rates and circular economy initiatives to mitigate this impact through resale, refurbishment, and recycling programs.

This dilemma forced many retailers to ask a crucial question: Are returns just an unavoidable cost of doing business, or could they be transformed into an opportunity for growth, efficiency, and competitive advantage?

The answer lies in reimagining how returns are managed, leveraging AI technology, automation, and data-driven strategies to unlock the hidden value buried within the reverse logistics process.

In this story, we follow Retail Galaxy, a fictional big box retailer caught in the middle of this challenge. Through their journey with ReturnPro, we explore how returns management is evolving from a costly headache into a strategic goldmine, one that is reshaping the future of retail.

A Retailer on the Brink

Meet RetailGalaxy, a fictional yet all-too-familiar enterprise retailer that sells a broad range of products from apparel to electronics. With over 200 physical stores, a thriving eCommerce channel, and over $6 billion in annual revenue, this company looked like a textbook success story. Behind the scenes, a silent crisis was chipping away at their margins as they were inefficiently processing 10,000 returns a week, draining their teams, and damaging their customer relationships.

Rising ReturnRates

Retail Galaxy’s online sales had tripled in five years, but so had their return rate, especially in fashion and electronics, where returns exceeded 30%. Customers ordering apparel would order multiple sizes and colors, known as “bracketing,” with the intention of returning most items. Electronics weren’t immune either, with a growing trend of product swaps, buyers’ remorse, and “wardrobing”, buying a product to use it briefly and then returning it for a full refund. Their legacy systems and logistics operations could not keep up.

Operational Chaos

Every returned item required manual inspection, repackaging, and decision-making. Refunds took days, sometimes weeks. Supply chain teams were overwhelmed. Returns sat in holding areas for indefinite periods due to a lack of disposition protocols. Employees had no standardized rules to determine if an item should be restocked, refurbished, recycled, or disposed.

While Retail Galaxy had automated supply chain processes, its returns management process was disjointed. POS/ERP systems were set up for forward logistics and were not optimized to efficiently manage returns. Email chains and side communications were used to communicate with vendors. What about the customers? They suffered from long refund cycles, which led to frustration and negative reviews.

Return Fraud and Abuse

The returns department also uncovered growing abuse. Besides wardrobing and bracketing, customers engaged in receipt fraud, using falsified or reused receipts to return products. Others returned counterfeit versions of high-value electronics or used and damaged items as if they were new. Without any intelligent detection or automation, Retail Galaxy had no defense against the returns fraud that was bleeding profits.

Environmental, Brand Pressure, and a Wake-Up Call

Sustainability, which was once a “nice-to-have” corporate goal, has evolved into a core brand value. Environmental, Social, and Governance mandates Retail Galaxy and businesses like them to reduce landfill waste, report on reverse supply chain efficiency, and prove environmental responsibility. Retail Galaxy was discarding over 25% of returned items. Landfill costs are surging. Stakeholders and customers are demanding better

Retail Galaxy had long viewed returns as a necessary evil, a post-sale liability to be written off, but mounting losses and reputational concerns are shifting that perspective.

The Search for a Returns Solution

Retail Galaxy explored traditional reverse logistics partners, legacy warehouse management systems, and niche return policy software, but none offered the integration, intelligence, and scale they needed. That’s when they discovered ReturnPro’s Returns Management Solution (Returns SaaS, Supply Chain and ReCommerce Services), specifically designed for enterprise-level returns management solutions.

Enter ReturnPro

ReturnPro’s returns management platform organized Retail Galaxy, enabling them to automate, streamline, and monetize their returns across six critical areas:

a. AI-Powered Dispositioning

At the heart of ReturnPro is AIRE – AI Returns Engine - an AI system making real-time decisions on returned inventory. Whether an item should be resold, repaired, recycled, donated, or liquidated was no longer a guessing game. The decision was founded on data-driven decision-making that removed human bias.

b. Seamless Customer Returns Portal

Customers could initiate returns without logging in, making the process quick and hassle-free. The self-service portal offered instant QR code generation, label-free drop-offs, and flexible resolution options like store credit or exchanges. Seamlessly integrated into Retail Galaxy’s existing platform, ReturnPro provided a brand-consistent, familiar interface that built trust and reinforced Retail Galaxy’s brand reputation.

c. Vendor Policy Hub

With hundreds of vendors and thousands of SKUs, Retail Galaxy needed to streamline returns and automate workflows. ReturnPro’s Vendor Hub solved this by centralizing vendor agreements, SLAs, and return rules into a single dashboard, dramatically cutting delays and disputes.

Vendors also benefited from transparent Return to Vendor (RTV) processes, ensuring every return aligned with pre-defined policies and credit guidelines. With 13 dedicated returns centers across the U.S., Canada, and Mexico, ReturnPro minimized touch points, reduced costs, and accelerated resolution times.

d. ReCommerce and Returns Liquidation

ReturnPro’s priority is to list returned inventory back to the original sales channel and when that is not possible, returns are resold across its proprietary wholesale and liquidation marketplaces as well as 20+ other channels. ReturnPro’s ReCommerce services bring returns back to life, turning the “return pile” into a revenue stream.

e. ERP, WMS, and POS Integration

ReturnPro does not require a rip-and-replace approach. It integrates seamlessly into Retail Galaxy’s existing infrastructure with minimal disruption, connecting with eCommerce, POS, CRM, 3P marketplaces, and other platforms across the reverse supply chain.

f. Sustainability at the Core

With carbon tracking, landfill diversion analytics, and donation reporting, ReturnPro also aligned with Retail Galaxy’s sustainability goals.

Go All In

After ReturnPro’s initial consultations and a deep dive into business operations and goals, the choice was clear. Retail Galaxy signed with ReturnPro, preparing for a company-wide rollout.

TheTransformation: Inside the ReturnPro Engine Room

ReturnPro’s implementation team worked hand-in-hand with Retail Galaxy’s operations, eCommerce, and Customer Experience leaders to initiate the transformation.

a. Customer Experience Upgrade

The new returns portal allowed for:

Instant QR-based drop-offs (no printer required)
Save-the-Sale, live exchange inventory options during return initiation
Trusted customers and “Keep-it” policies
Tracking updates and status visibility
Returns were initiated in under 60 seconds. Support calls dropped. NPS scores rose.

b. AI-Powered Dispositioning (AIRE)

AIRE’s algorithms evaluated over 100 datapoints per item—product type, return reason, damage level, location, vendor policy, and market demand.

Outcomes included:

Restockable items are auto-routed pending vendor policy
Refurbish-eligible items sent to one of ReturnPro’s facilities
Resellable items are listed on marketplace, wholesale, or liquidation sites
Donate-eligible items tracked for ESG reporting
Processing times dropped by 60%. Output improved, as well, less guesswork, more clarity.

c. Smarter Vendor Collaboration

ReturnPro’s Vendor Policy Hub turned outdated email chains into a living, digital ecosystem. Vendors could approve return types, issue authorizations, and track credit notes—all in one place.

Return-related disputes dropped by 42%. Vendors appreciated the transparency. Retail Galaxy gained leverage and speed.

d. ReCommerce + Inventory Recovery

The number of Items previously marked as losses was reduced, meaning greater recovery, enabling returns to find a new life. ReturnPro's ReCommerce engine lists returns on their proprietary wholesale and retail sites and across 20+ integrated marketplaces, maximizing recovery while minimizing resale costs.

RetailGalaxy tested one of the wholesale outlets listing lightly used tech. Within months, the value of recovered products made up for their investment.

e. The Dashboard: Analytics and Automation

ReturnPro’s dashboards became indispensable tools for presenting key return metrics and insights:

Daily return trends by channel, SKU, and region
Fraud alerts via pattern recognition and thresholds
Sustainability KPIs like landfill diversion, carbon savings
Policy effectiveness by vendor, category, and geography
The C-suite now had a real-time pulse on their reverse operations.

The Win: Measuring the Impact

Twelve months after launch, Retail Galaxy published a stunning internal report. Highlights included:

30% faster return processing
$3.8 million in labor and logistics savings
15% drop in fraud losses
$28 million inventory recovery through resale and returns liquidation
40% of returns diverted from landfill
22-point rise in customer satisfaction scores

ReturnPro had delivered not just operational improvements, but strategic transformation. Departments that once worked in silos—logistics, support, merchandising, sustainability—now collaborated around a single platform.

Future-Proofing Retail: What Retail Galaxy Learned

The journey fundamentally shifted how Retail Galaxy viewed returns. From Liability to Leverage, returns were no longer just a cost center. They became a source of:

Customer loyalty
Sustainability leadership
Data-driven decision-making
Revenue recovery

Returns Management as a Strategy

Leadership restructured returns into a separate department, with a VP of Reverse Operations reporting to the COO. Quarterly board meetings now include reverse supply chain performance metrics alongside forward logistics KPIs.

Your Returns Don’t Have to Be a Loss—They Can Be a Launchpad

The future of retail lies in agility, not just in selling, but in handling what comes back.With the right tools, the reverse supply chain can be as optimized, automated, and profitable as the forward one.

ReturnPro didn’t just fix a problem. It redefined a category. If you’re still viewing returns as a sunk cost, it’s time to flip the script, because buried in that “pile of problems” is something powerful: a hidden goldmine. ReturnPro is the map to uncover it.

‍

Note: Retail Galaxy is a fictional brand based on real-world retail scenarios to illustrate the impact of ReturnPro's platform.

Sources:

‍

Download a copy